Li Zhengshuan, Yang Zhijian
Abstract: The English Metaphysical poet John Donne is renowned as a “philosophical poet.” Behind his peculiar poetic style lies a unique creative conception. The distinctiveness of this creative conception owes significantly to the philosophical undertones it contains. Specifically, Donne’s creative conception manifests unparalleled philosophical characteristics in three aspects: progressive humanism, skepticism and critical thinking, and the dual dimensions of existence and nothingness. This article undertakes a deep philosophical examination of Donne’s creative conception, aiming to reveal the intellectual roots of his poetic uniqueness and to understand the profound ideas of this great poet more comprehensively from diverse perspectives.
Keywords: John Donne; English poetry; creative conception
1. Introduction
The Metaphysical poets constitute a uniquely distinctive group in the history of English—and indeed world—poetry. Characterized by abstruse thought, unconventional imagery, and idiosyncratic language, their works depart sharply from the dominant poetic conventions of the Elizabethan era and once occupied a central position in the literary landscape. John Donne (1572–1631) stands as the foremost figure of this group and the initiator of its distinctive poetic mode.
The English Renaissance was a period of profound complexity, marked by political instability, religious pluralism, and the collision of old and new intellectual paradigms. Such conditions often generated uncertainty and existential anxiety, to which Donne himself was deeply responsive. It was within this context of interwoven contradictions and tensions that Donne produced his innovative poetry. T. S. Eliot argued that “a thought to Donne was an experience.” (Eliot 287) As the leading Metaphysical poet, Donne possessed an exceptional capacity to transform abstract thought into lived experience, a quality evident in his manipulation of language, meter, and imagery. Beyond technical ingenuity, however, the originality of his poetry is inseparable from the philosophical orientation underlying his creative thought.
Readers of Donne’s poetry frequently remark upon its profound philosophical depth, often experiencing a sense of intellectual revelation upon completion. As critical engagement with his work expanded, Donne gradually acquired the reputation of a “philosophical poet.” Some scholars contend that his philosophical meditations on personal tragedy transcend specific historical and cultural contexts, characterizing him as “a poet as a philosophical being.” (Zhang 7) Others note that he articulates philosophically charged poetic content through monologue or implicit dialogue(Zhao and Li 2024, 34). These assessments collectively affirm the strong philosophical dimension of Donne’s poetry, a dimension closely tied to the intellectual currents of his age. Donne’s lifetime not only coincided with the height of the English Renaissance but also with the spread of skepticism across Europe. In addition, rapid social transformation and the erosion of traditional value systems compelled sustained reflection on individual existence, thereby shaping the philosophical substratum of his poetic vision.
Existing scholarship has largely concentrated on close readings of Donne’s poetic texts, while systematic attention to his creative philosophy remains limited. Yan Kui (1994) examines Donne’s thought through five conceptual lenses: cosmic reconstruction, the paradox of perpetual change, the spirit–flesh dichotomy, paradoxes of time and space, and individualized selfhood. Bai Xihan (2002) traces Donne’s poetic thought through his reflections on love, religion, death, and cosmic order, while Li Zhengshuan and Jia Xiaoying (2009) employ psychoanalytic criticism to explore his creative psychology. Despite these contributions, a comprehensive philosophical examination of Donne’s creative thought has yet to be undertaken. This study therefore approaches Donne’s poetry from three interrelated perspectives—progressive humanism, skepticism and critical thinking, and the dual dimensions of existence and nothingness—through close analysis of selected poems. By situating Donne’s creative thought within a broader philosophical framework, this paper seeks to clarify the intellectual origins of his distinctive poetic vision and to offer a more integrated account of the forces shaping his work.
2. Progressive Humanism
Renaissance in England has been described as “the most influential and also the most turbulent period in English history.” (Wu 2) Its far-reaching influence lay in the era’s groundbreaking advances in science and literature, as well as in the outward expansion of human thought, which stimulated intellectual vitality and brought about a fundamental transformation in prevailing modes of thinking (Yang 4). At the same time, the period was marked by persistent instability, as both political and religious structures were characterized by disorder and conflict. From another perspective, however, such disorder often functions as the prelude to a new order and as a catalyst for historical progress. Politically, the growing strength of the bourgeoisie led to escalating demands for power, intensifying conflicts with the feudal absolutist monarchy and ultimately culminating in the English Bourgeois Revolution. Oliver Cromwell’s execution of Charles I symbolized the overthrow of feudal monarchical absolutism and the establishment of a bourgeois republic, securing political power for the emerging bourgeois class in an unprecedented manner. Religiously, the dominant theocratic authority of the Middle Ages likewise declined with the onset of the Reformation. Initiated by Martin Luther in Germany, the movement soon extended to England, where Henry VIII severed ties with the Roman Catholic Church and promulgated the Act of Supremacy, transferring ecclesiastical authority from the papacy to the crown. Yet this reform, while ostensibly curtailing the power of the Church, merely replaced papal authority with royal supremacy and thus remained fundamentally incomplete. In response to this incompleteness, Calvinism—representing the interests of the emerging bourgeoisie—rose to prominence. “Advocating further purification of the Church and the elimination of ritual excess, its adherents came to be known as Puritans.” (Li 2) In 1649, under the banner of opposition to the established Church of England, they launched a civil war—also referred to as the Puritan Revolution—thereby pushing religious and political reform to a more radical stage.
Political and religious instability inevitably precipitates profound transformations in intellectual and cultural life. As the Renaissance originated in Italy and spread across Europe, England likewise became integrated into this progressive intellectual movement. Long-suppressed modes of thought were gradually liberated, and literature and the arts experienced renewed vitality. Since the advent of the Middle Ages, Christian theology had maintained ideological dominance, while asceticism imposed sustained restraints on human desire. Legitimate and natural human impulses were denied expression, and fear of losing divine salvation after death encouraged passive submission to a corrupt and decaying Church. This systematic suppression of human nature and intellectual freedom contributed to the prolonged stagnation often associated with the medieval period. With the arrival of the Renaissance, humanistic values reasserted themselves, challenging ecclesiastical authority and releasing natural human impulses from the constraints of ascetic doctrine. Although this major intellectual and cultural movement first emerged in Italy and subsequently spread throughout Europe, England’s own turbulent social conditions provided fertile ground for its reception and development. The English Renaissance thus resulted from the combined forces of external transmission and internal transformation. The most salient intellectual current of the Renaissance—indeed its defining Zeitgeist—was humanism. “Humanists advocated a shift toward a ‘human-centered’ worldview in opposition to the medieval theological model that placed God at the center of all meaning.” (Li 3) Emphasizing human value and dignity, humanism promoted the liberation of individuality, affirmed earthly life, and stressed the importance of education and scientific inquiry. Under the influence of these ideas, English literature flourished, producing a remarkable array of writers, including the gifted dramatist Christopher Marlowe, the great poet Edmund Spenser, and such versatile masters of both drama and poetry as William Shakespeare and Ben Jonson. Alongside these figures, however, emerged a group of poets whose style diverged sharply from prevailing Elizabethan aesthetic norms. Rejecting rhetorical ornamentation, they developed a poetic mode characterized by intellectual density, conceptual novelty, and formal complexity. These were the Metaphysical poets, among whom John Donne stands as the most prominent and influential representative.
Born into this historical moment and shaped by it throughout his life, Donne was inevitably influenced by the dominant intellectual current of the age—humanism. At a time when writers widely championed the liberation of human nature, the affirmation of desire, and a renewed attention to earthly life as central literary concerns, Donne was no exception. Like his contemporaries, he responded to the prevailing intellectual climate and literary conventions of the period, aligning his poetic practice with the spirit of the age in order to engage contemporary readers. Although Donne’s poetry is frequently marked by intellectually demanding conceits, paradoxes, and images forcefully juxtaposed, these features did not hinder its wide circulation or popularity. His work was well received not only among general readers but also among his literary contemporaries, including Ben Jonson. In the well-known poem “To John Donne”, Jonson offers Donne the highest praise, likening him to a favorite of Apollo and the Muses, before whom the talents of others pale by comparison. The poem’s conclusion elevates this admiration still further, as Jonson declares that while Donne fully merits exalted praise, the disparity between them is so great that excessive commendation might itself risk impropriety.
Donne was also a direct beneficiary of humanist thought, which exerted a formative influence on his poetic practice. “While his poetry frequently contains explicit or implicit representations of sexuality, such elements attest to Donne’s concern with the liberation of human nature and his affirmation of individual agency.” (Zhao and Li 2019, 95) By incorporating desire for the body and the experience of physical love into his verse, Donne embodies a humanist sensibility characteristic of the Renaissance, one that values sensory experience and corporeal existence(Lu 2010, 261). Among human desires, erotic love may be regarded as both the most natural and the most fundamental. Donne’s poetic treatment of erotic desire is often intense, yet in most cases remains within the bounds of contemporary acceptability. A small number of poems, however—notably “To His Mistress Going to Bed”—are strikingly bold in their frankness. The poem’s detailed depiction of sexual intimacy would be challenging even for many modern readers, let alone for audiences in a period when the liberation of human nature was still in its early stages. Nevertheless, despite its overt sensuality, the poem clearly demonstrates how Donne, under the influence of humanist thought, foregrounds natural human desire as a legitimate poetic subject. The urgency of liberation and the eruption of powerful emotion are palpable throughout the poem. Such a celebration of corporeal desire is rare in medieval literature and, in this sense, reflects a significant progressive departure from earlier literary traditions.
Poems that expose desire with such unmediated frankness are rare even within Donne’s oeuvre. In the majority of his works, emotional expression is intense, yet verbal articulation tends to remain partial, suggestive, and indirect. Songs and Sonnets comprises fifty-five love poems, most of which engage with erotic desire and sensual pleasure. As a poet, however, Donne was acutely aware of how to temper and veil such ardent emotion through language. Upon close reading, his seemingly rough poetic texture and colloquial diction release an overwhelming emotional force, erupting with the suddenness of a volcanic outburst and catching the reader unprepared. A striking example appears in the opening line of “The Canonization”:
For God’s sake hold your tongue, and let me love (Smith 47).
The speaker appears to be addressing an imagined interlocutor, one who has perhaps previously offered advice or admonition. Unpersuaded, the speaker responds with open defiance, sharply rebuking the interlocutor and ordering him to remain silent and cease his interference. So long as he is permitted to love, the speaker professes indifference to mockery or reproach. More than that, he reverses the roles of speaker and listener, assuming a position of authority by offering counsel of his own to the interlocutor:
With wealth your state, your mind with arts improve,
Take you a course, get you a place,
Observe his Honour, or his Grace,
Or the King’s real, or his stamped face
Contemplate; what you will, approve (Smith47),
The speaker urges his interlocutor to pursue any course of action he wishes, provided that he refrains from interfering with the speaker’s love. The poem opens in an angry, confrontational tone, with violent and incandescent emotion accumulating from the very first word and intensifying through a process of steady escalation. By the final word of the opening line, the emotional charge has reached a critical threshold, functioning almost like a precisely timed detonation within the textual space. As readers progress through the line, they participate in a parallel process of emotional anticipation; at the moment of completion, the long-contained intensity erupts, producing a powerful sensory and affective impact. Such emotional force is generated entirely by a single word—love. For love, the speaker is willing to endure reproach and abandon all else, a stance that may be read as an emphatic enactment of the humanist ideals of liberated desire and the affirmation of earthly pleasure. A similar dynamic appears in “The Sun Rising”, where Donne employs indirect and playful language to evoke the lovers’ sensual enjoyment:
Busy old fool, unruly Sun,
Why dost thou thus,
Through windows, and through curtains call on us? (Smith 80)
Here the poet imagines an intimate scene in which a pair of lovers engage in private pleasure within an enclosed space, while the sun functions as an aged and intrusive observer, peering through windows and curtains at their concealed intimacy. In Donne’s poetry, expressions of love are frequently accompanied by sexual metaphor; as Lu Feng observes, “the union of love and the body constitute a consistent preoccupation in Donne’s thought.” (Lu 2021, 152) Through such suggestive articulation, Donne is able to give poetic form to his underlying desire for the liberation of human nature and the affirmation of sensual pleasure. This strategy demonstrates the extent to which progressive humanist ideas are deeply inscribed in his creative thought.
3. Skepticism and Critical Thinking
Western skepticism has a long intellectual lineage, tracing its origins to ancient Greek philosophy more than 2,400 years ago. Protagoras advanced an early form of relativism, arguing that only an individual’s immediate sensory perception of a given moment can be regarded as genuine and reliable, and that beyond sensation there exists no universally valid or certain knowledge (Xie and Zhang 11). By taking momentary human perception as the sole criterion of truth, Protagoras denied the existence of objective knowledge independent of the subject, thereby laying the groundwork for early skeptical thought. More commonly, however, philosophical skepticism refers to the school founded by Pyrrho,whose ideas were transmitted by his disciple Timon and later incorporated into the broader tradition of Hellenistic philosophy. Over time, scholarly assessments of Pyrrhonian skepticism have varied considerably. Some critics have dismissed it as radical doubt pursued for its own sake, while others—drawing on the analyses of Sextus Empiricus—have emphasized its constructive dimension, arguing that skepticism represents “not mere confusion or uncertainty in the ordinary sense, but a persistent investigative pursuit of truth.” (Cui 58) Regardless of such divergent evaluations, it is clear that the Skeptics characteristically refrained from making definitive judgments, neither affirming nor denying propositions, but instead maintaining a deliberate suspension of judgment that kept the mind in a state of reflective openness.
By the seventeenth century, Continental rationalism initiated by Descartes began to spread across Europe. His famous dictum “I think, therefore I am” marked the advent of modern philosophy and was accompanied by the development of universal doubt as a method of inquiry. “Universal doubt, as the point of departure of Cartesian philosophy, serves both as a means to attain certainty and as the foundation of Descartes’s new philosophical system.” (Zhang 7) In order to establish a secure basis for knowledge, Descartes sought to dismantle the existing edifice of inherited beliefs and reconstruct it anew. The foundation of this reconstruction lay in maintaining doubt toward “all that he could not perceive clearly and distinctly.” (Li 28) It is important to note, however, that Cartesian universal doubt differs fundamentally from the suspension of judgment characteristic of ancient Greek skepticism. Whereas Pyrrhonian skepticism refrains from assent altogether, Descartes employs doubt precisely in order to arrive at clear and definitive judgments. His method does not involve indiscriminate or arbitrary skepticism but requires sufficient and rational justification (Zhan 67). Through this methodological use of doubt, Descartes reshaped the epistemological paradigm of Western philosophy. This commitment to sustained questioning and rigorous inquiry reflects a distinctly critical spirit: knowledge is not to be accepted wholesale but subjected to careful examination before assent is granted. In this respect, Cartesian rationalism, in contrast to ancient skepticism, embodies the progressive intellectual orientation of its historical moment.
Under the influence of universal doubt as an epistemological method, Donne’s writing likewise exhibits a pronounced skeptical tendency. As John Carey notes, “as an artist, he was fortunate to experience, within the range of his acute sensibility, the powerful surge of skepticism.” (Carey 231) As early as a letter written in 1613, Donne remarked that nothing is free from perplexity except proof in the mathematical sense. His inquiry into the limits of human cognition thus ultimately returns to abstract mathematics. In this respect, Donne may even be seen as anticipating Descartes, whose Meditations on First Philosophy was completed only in 1628—some fifteen years later. Skepticism, as a latent yet persistent element running through Donne’s intellectual life, is already discernible in his early works. “The Progress of the Soul” offers a particularly revealing example. In the final stanza, the poem’s closing three lines articulate Donne’s doubt concerning universally accepted values:
There’s nothing simply good, nor ill alone,
Of every quality comparison,
The only measure is, and judge, opinion. (Smith 193)
Moreover, Donne’s sermons from his later years continue to register a pronounced skepticism toward established knowledge. As he observes, “How imperfect our knowledge is. Is there anything we know perfectly?” (quoted in Lu 2010, 74) Taken together, these two examples—from an early long poem to late devotional prose—demonstrate that skepticism consistently accompanies Donne throughout his intellectual development, functioning as a significant source of his creative thought. The purpose of Donne’s skepticism differs both from the suspension of judgment characteristic of ancient Greek skepticism and from Descartes’s instrumental use of doubt as a means to secure epistemic certainty. Instead, it operates largely as a strategy for mediating internal contradictions and reconciling conflicting ideas. Living in a period marked by social upheaval and intellectual pluralism, Donne was acutely aware of the sensitivity of his historical environment and the risks inherent in overtly criticizing contemporary affairs. Yet as a thinker at the forefront of his age, he was equally conscious of the disintegration of traditional value systems, which generated profound inner tension. The struggle between classical intellectual inheritance and the demands of emerging modern life is fully inscribed in his experience(Li et al. 155). To conceal direct critique of reality while alleviating internal conflict, Donne adapted himself to the prevailing intellectual climate by adopting the mask of skepticism. This posture enabled him to articulate personal insights while maintaining acceptability among both the general public and those in positions of authority. In Donne’s poetry, skepticism thus functions not merely as a philosophical attitude but as a critical mode in practice—a mode that finds especially clear expression in his approaches to love and to science.
Donne’s attitude toward love is fundamentally conflicted. On the one hand, humanism—the spiritual core of the Renaissance—affirmed earthly life and sensual pleasure, and Donne’s youthful amorous exploits offer practical evidence of his deep immersion in the spirit of the age. On the other hand, at a more profound psychological level, Donne remained troubled by persistent anxiety and inner conflict stemming from his conversion to the Anglican Church(Lu 2021, 19). He transposed this act of religious defection into his love poetry: his break with Catholicism fostered a prolonged suspicion of female fidelity. This skepticism stands in tension with his simultaneous affirmation of natural love and harmonious relations between the sexes, generating an irreconcilable internal contradiction.As a result, Songs and Sonnets presents a wide spectrum of representations of love, “all circling around a painful central question—whether love can endure eternally—thereby revealing the poet’s shifting and often contradictory attitudes toward love.” (Lu 2010, 80) In poems such as “The Good Morrow”, “The Sun Rising”, and “The Anniversary”, Donne affirms love and praises women, portraying the beloved as incomparable. This exaltation culminates in poems such as “The Canonization” and “The Relic”, where secular love is invested with sacred significance and transformed into a form of holy love. By contrast, in “Song (Go, and catch a falling star)” and “The Message”, women appear inconstant and unfaithful, and love becomes fragile and unstable. When such suspicion reaches its extreme, women are stripped of human form altogether, reduced to the mummy in “Love’s Alchemy” or the ghost in “The Apparition”. To negotiate these contradictions, Donne adopts a sustained posture of skepticism, approaching love as a problem to be examined critically rather than resolved conclusively. He refrains from aligning himself fully with any single position or issuing definitive judgments. In this respect, his stance bears notable resemblance to Sextus Empiricus’s distinction between the “Ephektikos”, who “continually investigates without ever arriving at a conclusion,” and the “Zetetikos”, so named because of the relentless pursuit of truth (Cui 58). Guided by this skeptical spirit, Donne persistently interrogates the question of whether love can be eternal, yet never arrives at a determinate answer. Rather than abandoning the inquiry, he incorporates this unresolved tension into his poetic practice, transforming skepticism itself into a mode of critical exploration and sustaining the question through ongoing artistic engagement.
Beyond his treatment of love, Donne also adopts a critically skeptical stance toward emerging scientific knowledge, which he famously refers to as the “new philosophy”:
New Philosophy calls all in doubt,
The element of fire is quite put out;
The Sun is lost, and th’ earth, and no man’s wit
Can well direct him where to look for it. (Smith 276)
Although Donne frequently employs imagery drawn from astronomy, geometry, and alchemy—reflecting the advances of early modern natural science (Nan and Zhao 111)—these images also reveal a deeper intellectual tension. Competing forces exerted simultaneous influence over Donne’s mental world: the impact of new scientific thought on the one hand, and the authority of traditional education and inherited belief on the other. These forces stood in opposition, producing hesitation and inner conflict rather than easy resolution(Li et al. 154). This tension is particularly evident in Donne’s response to developments in astronomy. The Copernican heliocentric model posed a profound challenge to the long-dominant geocentric worldview. Given his wide-ranging intellectual interests, Donne could scarcely remain untouched by such revolutionary ideas. Yet his grounding in scholastic learning and his deeply rooted religious commitments compelled him to approach these new theories with caution, resisting premature judgment. Rather than accepting or rejecting them outright, Donne incorporates scientific controversy into his poetry as an object of critical inquiry. His deployment of solar imagery in poems such as “The Good Morrow” and “The Sun Rising” thus signals sustained engagement with the epistemological implications of the new science, reflecting a broader attempt to negotiate uncertainty through poetic exploration.
4. The Dual Dimensions of Existence and Nothingness
Existence and nothingness constitute central concerns of modern Western philosophy and have been the subject of sustained and wide-ranging debate. They also articulate a fundamental existential predicament confronted by modern individuals, particularly in the context of post-industrialization and the rise of consumer culture. Both concepts are notoriously complex and resistant to definitive interpretation. Competing philosophical positions have generated a proliferation of meanings, continually reconfiguring their conceptual cores and rendering any fixed or stable referent elusive.
Generally speaking, two distinct conceptions of “existence” may be identified within philosophical discourse. The first refers to existence in its ordinary or ontological sense, denoting “the concrete presence of particular entities—those that are perceptible, real, and situated within time and space.” (Wang and Wang 22) From the perspective of dialectical materialism, existence in this sense constitutes the precondition for the unity of the world. The second conception emerged with the epistemological turn of modern philosophy, in which “existence” came to signify the being of the thinking subject. Through the method of universal doubt, Descartes arrived at an indubitable foundation: the thinking “I.” The existence of the “I” as a thinking substance is beyond doubt, providing the groundwork for subsequent modern and contemporary philosophical inquiries into existence. In 1927, Martin Heidegger’s seminal work Being and Time further transformed the philosophical treatment of existence. In the introduction, he acknowledges that “the concept of ‘being’ is rather the most obscure of all.” (Heidegger 2) He argues that since Plato, Western philosophy has largely forgotten the question of Being itself, mistakenly conflating Being with beings. Accordingly, Heidegger opens his work by explicitly restating its central aim: to reawaken the question of the meaning of Being. As he puts it, “the fact that we live already in an understanding of being and that the meaning of being is at the same time shrouded in darkness proves the fundamental necessity of repeating the question of the meaning of ‘being’.” (Heidegger 3) Building upon this reorientation, Jean-Paul Sartre later deepened the discussion in Being and Nothingness, advancing the influential thesis that existence precedes essence and thereby further expanding the philosophical horizon of existential inquiry.
As for the concept of “nothingness,” its origins may be traced back to ancient Greek philosophy, notably to Anaximander’s notion of the apeiron (the “indefinite” or “boundless”), which denotes “the material principle from which all things arise—lacking fixed properties or form, free of determinate qualities, and eternal in nature.” (Lu 139) During the Middle Ages, when theology dominated intellectual life, major theologians such as Saint Augustine and Thomas Aquinas maintained that God created the world ex nihilo, where “nothingness” signifies absolute non-being. With the Renaissance dispelling the theological dominance of medieval thought, the status of the human subject rose steadily, and the Enlightenment further elevated human cognitive capacity under the authority of reason. In The Science of Logic, G. W. F. Hegel begins with the category of “pure being” and incorporates “nothing” into dialectical analysis. He demonstrates that “pure being,” devoid of any determination, is indistinguishable from “nothing”; the two are identical and mutually implicative. For Hegel, “nothing” is no longer the mere opposite of being but a necessary moment within dialectical movement, functioning as an internal motivation that propels conceptual development. Heidegger offers a profound reexamination of nothingness in What Is Metaphysics? arguing that “the ‘nothing’ does not signify the abandonment or negation of beings but rather a transcendence of beings as such.” (ibid.) Sartre further develops Heidegger’s insights by approaching nothingness through the lens of negation. For Sartre, nothingness derives its reality from the negating power of consciousness; the negativity inherent in existence itself constitutes nothingness.
In fact, throughout the history of philosophy, the concepts of being and nothingness are almost invariably co-present and mutually implicated. Any inquiry into one necessarily entails engagement with the other. Their relationship is neither parallel nor simply oppositional; rather, it is one of interweaving and bidirectional co-constitution. Ancient Greek philosophers approached the fundamental principle of the world through reflections on “nothing”; within theological discourse, God brings being forth from nothing in the act of creation; Hegel articulates the dialectical unity of “pure being” and “pure nothing”; Heidegger insists that nothingness is not the negation of being but the condition under which being can be disclosed; and Sartre argues that being is logically prior to nothingness, asserting that “it is from being that nothingness derives concretely its efficacy. This is what we mean when we say that ‘nothingness haunts being’.” (Sartre 49)
Traces of being and nothingness can likewise be discerned in Donne’s poetic thought, where they are embodied and articulated through concrete poetic forms. Donne was not a philosopher: he did not engage in systematic speculation on such questions, nor did he subject these concepts to rigorous theoretical analysis. Yet at the level of spiritual orientation, his work resonates across time with the concerns of modern and even contemporary philosophers. The turbulence of his age and the transformation of modes of thought compelled Donne to reflect repeatedly on the problem of human existence, incorporating such reflections into his creative practice and thereby shaping two fundamental dimensions of his poetic imagination. Donne’s life was marked by instability and rupture. His early education ended without distinction; his youth was characterized by dissipation; he later encountered true love and entered into a clandestine marriage, only to be imprisoned by his father-in-law. After his release, he lived in poverty, and in order to secure a livelihood was eventually compelled to convert to the Church of England in 1615. Whether in the hardships of his early wandering life or in his later religious transformation and entry into holy orders, the question of personal existence persistently haunted Donne. Closely bound up with this question was that of death. Sustained reflection on personal experience and religious doctrine led Donne to develop a distinctive conception of death, one that profoundly shaped his poetry. The shadow of death not only looms over his devotional verse but also permeates his love poetry. In contrast to Shakespeare’s sonnets—which, “by imitating the divine act of creation, are said to possess the power to overcome death” (Zeng 95)—Donne’s sonnets frequently betray a fear of death and a trembling before divine authority. Burdened by remorse and anguish over his conversion, Donne feared divine punishment and the possibility that, after death, he might be denied entry into heaven and thus eternal peace. Consequently, in his divine poems he often anticipates his own death as a means of seeking redemption. In Holy Sonnet I, he depicts a mutual rush toward death: “I run to death, and death meets me as fast.” (Smith 309) In Holy Sonnet III, confronted with the “coming ills”—that is, death—he finds no solace, fearing that his apostasy will preclude salvation. Even in the well-known Holy Sonnet X, “Death, Be Not Proud”, where he appears to confront death directly and defy its power, the gesture functions less as genuine triumph than as self-encouragement, a rhetorical bravado masking inner dread. A similar preoccupation with death appears in Donne’s love poetry. In “The Computation”, the speaker imagines himself as a ghost who continues to calculate the days since his lover’s departure; in “The Dampe”, the speaker envisions his posthumous dissection releasing a lethal vapor, unleashing a scene of massacre. Beyond these poetic imaginings, Donne also “harbored suicidal tendencies over a long period; he read and studied sociological works on suicide and engaged in sustained debate on the subject.” (Lu 2010, 109) In 1608, he composed Biathanatos, a treatise devoted specifically to suicide. The work is lengthy and obscure, and its arguments were highly provocative in its own time, readily inviting controversy and censure (Zhao and Li 2019, 98).
Donne’s reflection on the problem of existence is not confined to death alone; it also extends to love. As discussed above, Donne is caught in a profound tension between the enjoyment of love and skepticism toward it. In an effort to resolve this contradiction, he frequently shifts his poetic persona in his love poems—in other words, he transforms his form of existence. Rather than confining himself to the category of the “human” when contemplating love, Donne deliberately steps beyond the human realm, seeking a change in perspective that might offer a viable resolution to the emotional dilemmas that trouble him. In “Twicknam Garden”, in order to escape the humiliation inflicted by the mocking trees of the garden, the speaker implores Cupid to let him become “some senseless piece of this place” (Smith 82). He wishes to transform into a mandrake shaped like a human body, allowed to groan in that place, or into “a stone fountain,” condemned to weep there perpetually. As long as he no longer remains human—no longer bears the suffering imposed by love—he is willing to become anything at all. The beloved, too, frequently undergoes metamorphosis, no longer appearing in human form. In “Community”, women are transformed into fruit, presented for men to taste: some men sample lightly, others devour greedily, and still others discard them without remorse. Donne laments that “Changed loves are but changed sorts of meat” (Smith 49); once the flesh of the fruit is consumed, it is casually cast aside, and faithful, enduring love proves nowhere to be found. At the same time, Donne also depicts instances in which lovers jointly transform their modes of existence, as in “Aire and Angels”. In this poem, the man becomes an angel and the woman becomes air. According to traditional scholastic philosophy, angels are immaterial and incorporeal, the purest form of spirit, while air—colorless and tasteless—is the purest of material elements, yet still inferior to angels in purity. However, for an angel to manifest itself, it must rely on air, condensing it into mist or cloud in order to assume visible form. In this process, air, by being “worn” by the angel, acquires angelic purity in turn. Through this mutual transformation, the love between the male and female lovers is thus elevated and refined (Fu 54).
Existence and nothingness are two sides of the same coin. When transformations of existence no longer suffice to fill the profound void Donne experiences in relation to love, nothingness inevitably enters the scene. “A Nocturnall upon S. Lucies Day, being the shortest day” is among Donne’s most distinctive poems; some critics have even regarded it as the only poem in his oeuvre that can legitimately be labeled “modern”. The poem is pervaded by a somber, dark, and melancholic atmosphere, saturated with the speaker’s mourning for his deceased beloved. Since the beloved has irreversibly departed from the world, any further transformation of the speaker’s mode of being becomes meaningless. He therefore resolutely chooses to abandon all forms of existence and retreat into nothingness. While others in the world draw sustenance from the essence of things in order to survive, “I, by love’s limbec, am the grave / Of all, that’s nothing” (Smith 72). Confronted with the problem of his own existence, the speaker urgently interrogates himself in the poem, only to negate each possibility in turn, allowing intense emotion to surge through the lines:
Were I a man, that I were one,
I needs must know; I should prefer,
If I were any beat,
Some ends, some means; yea plants, yea stones detest,
And love; all, all some properties invest;
If I an ordinary nothing were,
As shadow, a light, and body must be here. (Smith 72–73)
Through this relentless process of questioning and self-negation, the speaker ultimately arrives at a definitive conclusion: he is “nothing.” No being in the world can confer upon him a form through which he might exist. He can only become absolute nothingness, carrying the pain of his beloved’s death and the unresolved question of eternal love, dissolving into chaos and finally vanishing into nothingness.
Conclusion
Philosophy, in its original sense, denotes the “love of wisdom.” The pursuit of wisdom is at once an unceasing exploration of elevated thought and a perpetual inquiry into the essence of existence. Exceptionally erudite and intellectually curious, John Donne pursued knowledge across both scientific and theological domains, a lifelong endeavor that accords with the Metaphysical poets’ emphasis on wit. Whether deliberately or instinctively, Donne incorporated his intellectual resources into poetic composition, endowing his works with a pronounced philosophical texture and earning him the designation of a “philosophical poet.” The humanist movement of the Renaissance proclaimed that “man is the measure of all things,” foregrounding natural human desire and affirming the value of earthly life. Donne’s poetry bears the unmistakable imprint of this progressive humanist spirit, most vividly in his enduring love poems. Taken as a whole, these poems may be read as a figurative, capitalized “Man”: they encompass joy and sorrow, union and separation, life, aging, illness, and death, thereby fully displaying the diversity and complexity of human existence. While Cartesian rationalism ushered reason into early modern Europe, it also fostered a pervasive climate of doubt. Under this influence, Donne’s writing exhibits a marked skepticism; yet beneath this skeptical surface lies a sustained, critical meditation on the question of whether love can attain permanence. Beyond this, Donne’s poetry engages the human condition along the twin axes of existence and nothingness. Death and love constitute two fundamental problems of human life. Born into a religious family and later ordained into the clergy, Donne approached death with grave seriousness in his devotional poetry. At the same time, his love poetry reveals how love, in its overwhelming force, can both invigorate human existence and abruptly reduce it to emptiness. Donne’s lovers repeatedly transform their forms of being, and, when such transformations fail, retreat into nothingness itself in search of solace or resolution to love—arguably the most intricate and elusive of human experiences.
It is precisely this quality that marks Donne as a poet of striking modernity. The philosophical dimensions of his poetic thought possess a transhistorical resonance. Humanism urges attentiveness to worldly life and the present moment; skepticism cultivates critical reflection; and the dual meditation on existence and nothingness compels continual examination of the meaning of being human. Donne’s life was turbulent and precarious, marked by personal loss, spiritual conflict, and material hardship. Yet even amid these struggles, he persistently sought an existential outlet. His poetry—condensed from lived experience and infused with enduring value—not only illuminates the past, but speaks to the present and gestures toward the future.
Works Cited
Carey, John. John Donne: Life, Mind and Art. Oxford University Press, 1981.
Cui, Yanqiang. “Doubt as Inquiry: On the Significance of Greek Skepticism”. Philosophical Reseach, no. 2, 1995, pp. 58–65.
Eliot, T. S. “The Metaphysical Poets.” Selected Essays by T. S. Eliot, edited by T. S.Eliot, Faber and Faber Ltd., 1951, pp. 281–291.
Fu, Hao. Selected Poems of John Donne. Foreign Language Teaching andResearch Press, 2014.
Heidegger, Martin. Being and Time. Trans. Joan Stambaugh. State Universityof New York Press, 1996.
Li, Li. “Marionetting God and Reconstructing the World: Descartes’ Revision andUtilization of Ancient Skepticism”.Fudan Journal (Social Sciences Edition), vol. 67,no. 5, 2025, pp. 19–29.
Li, Weiping, and Zhang Dingquan et al. A History of British Literary Thought. Shanghai Foreign Language Education Press, 2012.
Li, Zhengshuan. Studies on British Renaissance Poetry. Hebei UniversityPress, 2006.
Lu, Shuying. “An Interpretation on Satre’s ‘Neant’”. Journal of Beijing NormalUniversity (Social Sciences), no. 3, 2012, pp. 139–144.
Lu, Yuming. The Study of Donne’s Love Poetry. Academia Press, 2010.
———. John Donne: A Critical Reader. East China NormalUniversity Press, 2021.
Nan, Jianchong, and Zhao Yan. “Contemporary Reflections on John Donne’s Poetry:The Poetic Perspective of Sensibility and Intellect” Journal of Xi’an InternationalStudies University, vol. 28, no. 2, 2020, pp. 111–113.
Satre, Jean-Paul. Being and Nothingness. Trans. Hazel E. Barnes. Washington Square Press, 1966.
Smith, A. J. John Donne: The Complete English Poems. Penguin BooksLtd., 1971.
Wang, Zisong, and Wang Taiqing. “About ‘Cunzai’ and ‘Shi’”. Fudan Journal (SocialSciences Edition), no. 1, 2000, pp. 21–36.
Wu, Di. The Study of English Metaphysical Poetry. China Social SciencePress, 2013.
Xie, Baojun, and Zhang Tong. “Evolution and Patterns of Thinking of Western Skepticism Epistemology”. Journal of Hit (Social Sciences Edition), no. 3, 2003, pp.10–15.
Yang, Zhouhan. English Literature in Seventeen Century. ShanghaiPeople’s Publishing House, 2016.
Zeng, Li. “Defeating Death by Creation: The Concept of Death in Shakespeare’sSonnets”. Foreign Languages and Literature, vol. 40, no. 3, 2024, pp. 88–97.
Zhan, Yuguo. “The Impact of Descartes’ Method of Doubt”. Journal of BeijingAdministration Institute, no. 6, 2000, pp. 65–68.
Zhang, Xuchun. “Internal Tension: Li Shangyin and John Donne as PhilosophicalBeings”. Foreign Languages and Literature no. 3, 1998, pp. 8–13.
Zhang, Ying. “On Descartes’ Quest for the Certainty of Knowledge”. TheoryResearch, no. 15, 2012, pp. 7–8.
Zhao, Ye, and Li Zhengshuan. “A Philosophical Perspective Study of Donne’sPluralistic Views on Death”. Foreign Language Research, vol. 36, no. 5, 2019, pp. 95–99.
———. “A Corpus-Based Study of the Language Style in JohnDonne’s Love Poetry”. Technology Enhanced Foreign Language Education, no. 3,2024, pp. 34–39+113.
The Authors
Li Zhengshuan, professor at the School of Foreign Studies in Hebei Normal University, Ph.D. of Peking University, Honorary Doctorate of University of Stirling, Ph.D. supervisor. His major research directions are English and American poetry, E-C & C-E translation of poetry, criticism of poetry translation. He has led national and provincial social sciences projects and served as a member of the Ministry of Education’s English Branch of the Steering Committee for Teaching Foreign Language and Literature, Vice Chair of the China Association for Comparative Studies of English and Chinese, Vice Chair of the China Ethnic Languages Translation Association, and Standing Council Member of the Translators Association of China.
Email:zhengshuanli@126.com
Yang Zhijian, a native of Zhangjiakou, Hebei Province, is currently pursuing a Master’s degree in English Language and Literature at School of Foreign Studies, Hebei Normal University, specializing in the studies of British literature and literary translation. He has published 4 articles.